The Role of Credit Score in Car Insurance Rates in the USA
In the United States, your credit score plays a significant role in determining your car insurance premiums. While it may seem unrelated, insurers consider credit information as a predictor of risk. Understanding how and why your credit affects your car insurance can help you save money and make more informed financial decisions.
Why Do Insurers Use Credit Scores?
Insurance companies use a version of your credit report to develop what's known as an “insurance score.” This score helps predict the likelihood that a driver will file a claim. Studies have shown that individuals with lower credit scores tend to file more claims, so insurers view them as higher risk.
What Credit Factors Affect Insurance Rates?
Not all credit factors are considered equally. Insurers typically use the following elements:
-
Payment history: Late or missed payments may raise red flags.
-
Credit utilization: High balances on credit cards can negatively impact your score.
-
Length of credit history: Longer credit histories are viewed more favorably.
-
Types of credit: A mix of installment loans and revolving credit helps.
-
New credit inquiries: Too many recent applications can hurt your score.
Note: Insurers use a different scoring model than lenders, so your credit-based insurance score may not be the same as your FICO score.
States That Restrict Use of Credit in Insurance
Some states have recognized that using credit scores can disproportionately affect low-income or minority groups and have taken steps to restrict or ban the practice. These include:
-
California
-
Hawaii
-
Massachusetts
-
Michigan (to a certain extent)
If you live in one of these states, your credit score may not impact your premiums.
How Much Can Credit Affect Premiums?
Drivers with poor credit can pay up to 50% to 100% more for car insurance compared to those with excellent credit. In some cases, poor credit can affect premiums more than a DUI conviction or an at-fault accident.
How to Improve Your Credit-Based Insurance Score
-
Pay bills on time – This is the most critical factor.
-
Lower your credit card balances – Aim to keep utilization below 30%.
-
Avoid opening too many new accounts.
-
Monitor your credit report for errors – You can get a free report annually from the three major bureaus.
-
Establish a longer credit history – Avoid closing old accounts unnecessarily.
How to Shop for Insurance with Poor Credit
If you have a low credit score:
-
Compare quotes from multiple providers—some weigh credit less heavily than others.
-
Ask about usage-based insurance programs that focus on driving behavior instead of credit.
-
Look for discounts (multi-policy, good driver, etc.) to offset the higher rate.
Conclusion
Credit scores are a major factor in U.S. car insurance pricing. While you can't change your score overnight, understanding how it affects your premium and working to improve it can result in significant long-term savings.